As it stands now, Alfredo Andrade will cover three positions: Superintendent, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services, and Chief Human Resources Officer.
In a press release on Thursday announcing the naming of Alfredo Andrade as interim superintendent of Perris Union High School District, board President Edward Garcia said, “Transforming a school district is a deliberate, sustained effort.”
PUHSD officials have never really described why a “transformation” was needed, but their actions over the last two years continue to make news. The board’s decision to name the district’s head of Human Resources as interim superintendent is the latest development that leaves questions unanswered about the transition of power in PUHSD.
Superintendent Jose Luis Araux announced in August that he is retiring at the end of the calendar year. Three months later, the district still has not posted the job opening on Edjoin, the website used nationally by education job seekers. And now, with the announcement this week that Andrade has been named interim superintendent effective Jan. 1, 2027, the district is turning over its highest leadership position to someone with no experience as an educator.
Andrade, whose background is in Human Resources administration in the private sector, was hired two years ago by PUHSD. One could argue that he now has experience in the education sector, but the fact remains that Andrade does not meet the district’s own job qualifications for superintendent.
Andrade has never been an assistant superintendent. He has never been a principal. He has never even been a teacher. That puts him in a very small group nationwide of individuals who have been named district superintendent without ever being an educator.
In the last two decades, questions have been raised about whether a district superintendent needs prior classroom experience as a prerequisite for the position – something most districts require. In 2011, the website governing.com addressed the issue, looking at rare cases across the country that have produced varying results:
— Cathie Black, a magazine executive who had never been an educator, was named New York City Schools Chancellor in 2010, receiving a state waiver to do so. Amid public outcry, she resigned after three months on the job.
— Retired Air Force Maj. Gen. John Barry had no education experience when he was hired as superintendent in Aurora, Colorado. But he served seven successful years and was named State Superintendent of the Year.
— Former investment banker and newspaper executive Austin Beutner served as the superintendent of the Los Angeles Unified School District for more than three years, although he faced criticism for his prior lack of experience as an educator.
When Andrade was hired in 2024, PUHSD board members amended the job description for the HR position, allowing him to be hired without experience as an educator. In addition, he faced criticism because of his prior relationship with three PUHSD board members. Andrade served as campaign treasurer for board member Anthony T. Stafford in 2020, while his wife Daniele served the same role for board members Edward Garcia in 2022 and Jamie Anaya in 2024.
When fellow cabinet member and Assistant Superintendent of Business Services Marguerite Williams was fired last month, Andrade was given authority over that department as well as his HR duties. Ironically, Williams is still listed on the website as head of the Business Department.
Williams has not been replaced. So as it stands now, Andrade would hold three positions in the cabinet, with Assistant Superintendent of Education Shanna Egans the only other cabinet member. And according to the district website, Andrade isn’t eligible to serve as superintendent at all.
The job description for superintendent on the PUHSD website includes “minimum of five years’ teaching experience” and “five years of successful administrative experience, including a principalship”. Andrade has neither. The only way the district could legally get around that is to take action citing State Education Code 35029, which states that, “A local governing board may waive any credential requirement for the chief administrative officer of the school district under its jurisdiction. Any individual serving as the chief administrative officer of a school district who does not hold a credential may be required by the local governing board to pursue a program of in-service training conducted pursuant to guidelines approved by the commission.”

Jose Luis Araux has been PUHSD superintendent for two years.
Araux and Garcia did not respond Friday to a request for comment on the situation. The only response came from Anna Fetzner, assistant to the superintendent, who clarified the previous press release by stating that Andrade’s appointment as interim superintendent won’t begin until Jan. 1, 2027.
In the press release issued on Thursday, Garcia said the following:
“Our students deserve a district that is structurally sound, exceptionally well-managed, and equipped with outstanding teachers, counselors, and educational leaders who can deliver an excellent education in every classroom. That requires that we continue to work on thoughtful reform, disciplined management, and sustained commitment over time.
“Mr. Andrade brings a deep understanding of our district, its people, and the organizational systems that support student success. His experience in human resources and organizational leadership positions him to guide the next phase of our work while ensuring a smooth transition. We believe meaningful progress begins with aligned leadership, clear priorities, and accountability at every level.”
Among the unanswered questions are:
— How much of a raise will Andrade receive? Although it is unclear at what step on the salary scale Andrade is currently placed for HR head, it appears he is making around $250,000 per year. Step 1 for superintendent is $307,000, according to the district website. But is that where he would be placed? Araux was placed at step 4 by the board when he was hired in 2024, and he currently makes $332,840, according to a contract amendment approved by the board in August.
— Will the board attempt to take action to make Andrade eligible as a permanent superintendent?
— When will a new Assistant Superintendent of Business Services be hired?
— Will Andrade continue to serve a dual role as interim superintendent and HR head after Jan. 1?
— What should district officials say to critics who say Andrade’s fast climb up the ladder is payoff for helping three board members get elected?
It’s obvious that PUHSD has taken a new direction in the last two years. How far will that change in direction go? Should these changes be described as “shameful”, as one source put it in a conversation this week?
Only time will tell.






